Access the full Bloodstone Capital Research platform — AI-powered intelligence, portfolio tracking, real-time market data and more.

Enquire →
Commodities17 November 2026 · 2,371 words · 11 min read

Silver analysis — 2026-11-17

silversilver-institutemetals-focuslbmaetpsolarcftcchinadeficitnovember-2026

The Silver Institute still forecasts a sixth consecutive deficit in 2026, but at 35 million ounces it is a quarter smaller than the figure published in April. After projected net disinvestment from exchange-traded products, its adjusted balance becomes a surplus of 10 million ounces. That reverses 2025, when fund buying added substantially to the demand for available metal. Our October analysis asked why a widening deficit coincided with a falling price, and the revised figures go some way to answering it.

TL;DR

  • The Silver Institute and Metals Focus forecast a 2026 deficit of 35 Moz, against 46.3 Moz in April's World Silver Survey. Demand is expected to fall 5% to 1,081 Moz and supply 3% to 1,045 Moz.
  • Including projected net ETP outflows of 45 Moz, the adjusted balance becomes a 10 Moz surplus. In 2025 the same measure was a shortfall of 332 Moz.
  • The 2025 deficit has been revised to 54 Moz from 40.3 Moz, an increase of about a third.
  • Industrial demand outside photovoltaics rises 4.5% to 492 Moz, but total industrial demand falls 3% to 640 Moz, implying solar silver demand of around 148 Moz, about a fifth lower than in 2025.
  • Recycling rises 6% to 210 Moz, the highest since 2012, while mine production edges down 0.5% to 834 Moz.
  • London vault silver fell 0.33% to 28,889 tonnes in October, the first monthly decline after the third-quarter rise we reported, while all three Chinese inventory measures fell.
  • COMEX December silver closed at $46.859 on 16 November and traded at about $47.45 on the morning of 17 November, around 61% below January's record. Managed Money net length has fallen to 3,615 contracts from 5,619 on 13 October.

The Deficit Narrows, and ETP Selling Offsets It

The Silver Institute's revised estimates, presented by Metals Focus in New York on 12 November, change the size of the 2026 shortfall more than its direction. It remains a deficit, the sixth in succession, but at 35 Moz it is 11.3 Moz smaller than the April forecast.

Measure, Moz20252026EChange
Total supply1,0781,045−3%
Total demand1,1321,081−5%
Market balance−54−35
Net investment in ETPs+278−45
Market balance less ETPs−332+10

Source: Silver Institute and Metals Focus, 12 November 2026. 2026 figures are estimates. Totals are rounded independently; the market balance is the Silver Institute's reported estimate and may not equal the difference between the displayed rounded figures.

The Silver Institute forecasts a 35 Moz deficit before ETP flows. After incorporating projected net ETP disinvestment of 45 Moz, its adjusted balance becomes a 10 Moz surplus. This is an annual forecast accounting for investment flows, not a measurement of freely available physical silver, and the 45 Moz is Metals Focus's full-year projection. The observed figure to date is different: global ETP holdings stood at 1.25 billion ounces on 3 November, down 55 Moz since the start of the year, although funds have bought back 24 Moz since the end of June.

The Silver Institute draws the connection itself, noting that the narrower shortfall and metal released through ETP selling have helped ease physical market tightness. A deficit describes the gap between fabrication, coin and bar demand and new supply. Whether that gap translates into scarcity also depends on whether investors are adding to holdings or releasing them.

2025 Looks Different in Hindsight

The revision to last year is as significant as the new forecast. April's survey put the 2025 deficit at 40.3 Moz. The November figures put it at 54 Moz, an increase of about 34%, and they show 278 Moz flowing into ETPs over the year. On the Silver Institute's adjusted measure, the balance less ETPs was a shortfall of 332 Moz in 2025.

That figure describes a balance that includes investment accumulation, and it does not mean that 332 Moz of physical demand went unmet. What it does show is that ETP accumulation added substantially to the demand for available metal, intensifying physical-market tightness beyond that implied by the underlying fabrication balance. That is the background to January's record of $121.65 an ounce and the tight London liquidity the Silver Institute describes at the time. In 2026 the investment flow has reversed, and the same structural shortfall sits alongside projected fund selling. The cumulative deficit for 2021 to 2026 is approximately 746 Moz, but the annual figures show how much of the market's tightness depended on what investors were doing in a given year.

Solar Silver Demand Falls by About a Fifth

Our October analysis noted that the LBMA had identified copper substitution in solar panels, and that its scale had not been quantified. The November estimates provide a measure of the overall reduction in photovoltaic demand. Total industrial demand is forecast to fall 3% to 640 Moz, while industrial demand outside photovoltaics rises 4.5% to 492 Moz. The difference implies photovoltaic demand of about 148 Moz in 2026, against about 186 Moz in 2025, a decline of roughly a fifth.

That estimate quantifies the total fall in solar silver demand, not its division between causes. The Silver Institute attributes it to installations falling short of expectations, particularly in China, and to record prices accelerating thrifting and substitution. The three have different implications. Lower installations can recover with the solar market, whereas reduced silver loadings and a change in metallisation technology, once qualified and in production, are not readily reversed when silver becomes cheaper. The release does not say how much of the decline each accounts for.

Outside solar, industrial demand is resilient. Automotive use is supported by vehicle electrification and charging infrastructure, and brazing alloys and solders are expected to edge higher. Even after this year's decline, total industrial demand is projected at around 22% above its 2019 level and the fourth-highest in Metals Focus's series.

The larger reductions are in consumer demand. Jewellery is forecast to fall 22% to 148 Moz and silverware 17% to 35 Moz, with higher prices and weaker rural spending in India encouraging smaller purchases. Bar and coin demand falls a more modest 2% to 215 Moz, with US retail investment expected at its lowest since 2010.

Supply: Recycling Responds to Price

Total mine production is forecast to edge down 0.5% to 834 Moz, as lower output in Peru, China and Argentina offsets gains in Mexico, Russia and Morocco. Primary silver mine production rises 6.5 Moz to 233 Moz, and Mexican output 6.6 Moz to 174 Moz, helped by improved grades and recoveries at Peñasquito, the restart of Tizapa and Terronera's first full year of commercial production. Because most silver is mined as a by-product, overall mine supply responds little to the silver price itself.

Recycling has responded. It is forecast to rise 6% to 210 Moz, the highest since 2012, driven mainly by industrial scrap but with jewellery recycling also rising in China, India and Turkey as high prices encourage selling. Primary producers' all-in sustaining costs rose 47% to $16.27 an ounce in the first half, and margins rose 187% to $62.19, but those margins were earned at first-half prices far above current levels.

Visible Stocks: The Evidence Is Mixed

The October analysis was built partly on London vault holdings rising through the third quarter, and it asked whether that rebuild would continue. The LBMA's October data show it paused. London vault silver fell 0.33% to 28,889 tonnes at the end of October, from the 28,985 tonnes reported for September. LBMA totals include metal held for ETPs, so they do not measure freely available supply.

Chinese stocks fell more clearly. As reported in our China Precious Metals Intelligence of 16 November, SMM's social inventory fell 111 tonnes to 3,689 tonnes, Shanghai Futures Exchange registered warrants fell 36.061 tonnes to 1,336.580 tonnes in the week to 13 November, and the Shanghai Gold Exchange's designated-warehouse stocks fell 39.420 tonnes in the week to 6 November. SMM attributes the latest draw mainly to buying on lower prices rather than to stronger demand.

The visible inventory evidence is therefore mixed. London stocks declined marginally in October, Chinese inventories have drawn, and COMEX holdings require separate assessment of registered and eligible metal. These observations do not establish a renewed global shortage, but neither do they demonstrate an unrestricted pool of available supply.

Price and Positioning

COMEX December silver closed at $46.859 an ounce on 16 November, after $49.121 on 13 November and $50.065 on 12 November, a fall of 6.4% over two sessions. It recovered slightly in early trading on 17 November to about $47.45. That is around 61% below January's record. The Silver Institute notes the gold to silver ratio, which fell to 43 in January, its lowest since 2011, had returned to the high 70s by early November.

Managed Money positioning has followed the price lower. In the CFTC report for 10 November, net length stood at 3,615 contracts, or 3.1% of open interest, against 5,619 on 13 October. The latest week brought a small decline, with gross longs down 340 contracts and gross shorts up 80. The report predates the falls of 12 to 16 November.

The Silver Institute attributes the retreat in prices to shifting US interest rate expectations, dollar strength and rising bond yields, which have weighed on the precious metals complex as a whole. US consumer prices rose 0.4% in October, above expectations, and CME data reported by SMM on 13 November priced an 86.8% probability of a quarter-point Federal Reserve increase at the 8 to 9 December meeting, with the remainder on a half point. Higher yields raise the cost of holding a metal that pays no income, and they bear directly on ETP flows.

Key Risks

The forecasts are estimates. The 2026 figures are preliminary, and the 2025 deficit has already been revised up by about a third since April. Further revisions are likely when the World Silver Survey is published next year.

ETP flows can reverse quickly. The difference between the adjusted 10 Moz surplus and a significant shortfall rests on fund flows. Funds bought 24 Moz between June and early November, and renewed inflows would tighten the market without any change in fabrication demand.

Solar's decline has several causes. Weaker installations, lower loadings and substitution all reduce demand, but only the first is likely to reverse if the solar market recovers. The release does not separate them.

Vault totals are not free float. London holdings include ETP metal, and a small monthly change does not establish how much silver is available to buyers.

Interest rates remain the dominant external influence. Market pricing points to a further US rate increase in December, and the direction of yields has a direct bearing on investment demand.

The Bottom Line

The Silver Institute's November estimates narrow the 2026 deficit to 35 Moz and project fund selling large enough to turn the adjusted balance into a 10 Moz surplus, against a 332 Moz shortfall on the same measure in 2025. That contrast explains much of what our October analysis could not. Last winter's tightness rested heavily on investment demand added to the structural shortfall, and that investment flow is now projected to run the other way.

The structural picture has not disappeared. Industrial demand outside solar is still growing, mine supply is flat and the deficit is the sixth in succession. But solar silver demand has fallen by about a fifth, jewellery by more, and recycling has risen to its highest since 2012. Visible stocks give no clear signal, with a small fall in London and a draw in China that SMM attributes to price-driven buying. For the deficit to regain influence over the price, the investment flow will need to turn, and with US yields rising that has not yet happened.

FAQ

Is silver still in deficit in 2026? Yes, on the Silver Institute's headline measure. It forecasts a deficit of 35 Moz, the sixth consecutive year, down from 46.3 Moz in its April forecast.

Why does silver show a surplus as well as a deficit? The headline balance excludes exchange-traded products. Metals Focus projects net ETP outflows of 45 Moz in 2026, so its adjusted balance including those flows is a surplus of 10 Moz. That is a forecast, not a measure of freely available metal.

How much has solar demand for silver fallen? The release forecasts total industrial demand of 640 Moz and demand outside photovoltaics of 492 Moz, implying solar demand of about 148 Moz, roughly a fifth lower than in 2025. The release does not separate lower installations from thrifting and substitution.

Have London silver stocks started to fall? Slightly. LBMA data show London vault holdings down 0.33% to 28,889 tonnes at the end of October, after rising through the third quarter.

How far has silver fallen from its record? COMEX December silver closed at $46.859 on 16 November and traded at about $47.45 on the morning of 17 November, around 61% below the record of $121.65 set on 26 January.

Data and source note: Supply, demand and balance figures are from the Silver Institute's release of 12 November 2026 and its accompanying table, prepared by Metals Focus; 2026 figures are estimates. The photovoltaic figures for 2025 and 2026 are derived from the published totals for industrial demand and industrial demand excluding photovoltaics, and are not separately published. The April comparison is the World Silver Survey 2026 as reported in our October analysis. London vault holdings are LBMA month-end figures. Chinese inventory figures are as published in our China Precious Metals Intelligence of 16 November 2026. COMEX prices are daily closes for the December 2026 contract, with the 17 November figure an early-trading quotation from CNBC rather than a close, and they are not directly comparable with the intraday spot observation of 19 October cited in our previous analysis. Federal Reserve probabilities are CME data as reported by SMM on 13 November. Positioning is from the CFTC Disaggregated Commitments of Traders, Futures Only, Managed Money, for positions as at 10 November 2026.

Sources

The Silver Institute, Silver Market Set for Sixth Consecutive Annual Deficit in 2026, 12 November 2026

The Silver Institute and Metals Focus, Silver Supply and Demand table, November 2026

LBMA, London Vault Data

Bullion World, COMEX silver futures daily prices

CNBC, Silver futures quote

US Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Disaggregated Commitments of Traders, Futures Only, positions dated 10 November 2026

Shanghai Metals Market, Tin midday review, 13 November 2026

Bloodstone Research, China Precious Metals Intelligence: Silver Stocks Fall Again as Gold Retreats 3.6%, 16 November 2026

Bloodstone Research, CFTC Precious Metals Positioning Intelligence: Platinum Returns to Net Long as Gold Shorts Fall, 17 November 2026

Previous edition: Bloodstone Research, Silver analysis, 19 October 2026

This document is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. Data and estimates may be revised. Independent financial advice should be sought before making any investment decision.